The B2B Podcast Index
Index
All categories
MarketingSalesSaaSFinanceHROpsLeadershipCustomer SuccessAI & DataProductStartups & FoundersRevOpsEngineering & DevTools
MethodologySubmit
Best of:MarketingSalesSaaSFinanceHROpsLeadershipCustomer SuccessAI & DataProductStartups & FoundersRevOpsEngineering & DevTools
An independent project byFame
SearchBest episodesGuestsInsightsMethodologySubmit a podcast
Index/Customer Success/The Customer Success Playbook
The Customer Success Playbook artwork

Customer Success Playbook Podcast S3 E71 - Adrian Swinscoe - Unlocking Value in Customer Journeys

The Customer Success Playbook · 2025-08-20 · 9 min

0:00--:--

Key moments - from our scoring

Substance score

28 / 100

Five dimensions, 20 points each

Insight Density5 / 20
Originality6 / 20
Guest Caliber8 / 20
Specificity & Evidence5 / 20
Conversational Craft4 / 20

Adrian Swinscoe returns to discuss the paradox of friction reduction in customer experience - specifically how removing all friction can backfire on retention despite improving signup metrics. Drawing on research from UserTesting's former CEO Andy McMillan, Swinscoe breaks down the critical distinction between good friction and bad friction using a real-world case study where a company stripped out steps they assumed were effort-intensive, only to discover those steps were actually value-defining parts of the customer relationship. For customer success leaders, product managers, and operations teams wrestling with efficiency goals, this conversation reframes the conversation: the effort customers expend during onboarding and choice architecture can be precisely what seals loyalty. Swinscoe recommends a deliberate, data-driven approach combining quantitative metrics with customer interviews to identify which friction points genuinely harm the business versus which ones drive emotional connection and long-term retention.

Key takeaways

  • →Not all friction is bad - removing steps that customers find valuable can destroy retention even when it increases signups, so you must distinguish between good and bad friction.
  • →Value-creating friction is often the effort required for customers to make meaningful choices and customize their experience, which builds emotional connection and relationship strength.
  • →Decisions about streamlining customer journeys must be based on data analysis and direct customer conversations rather than assumptions that all effort is negative.
  • →Balancing operational efficiency with customer connection requires deliberately examining each touchpoint to understand whether it's a genuine pain point or a value-delivering interaction.
  • →Over-simplification of customer processes can backfire by removing the human and emotional connection that actually drives long-term customer loyalty.

In this episode

  1. 1Introduction to Adrian Swinscoe and His Background
  2. 2Edinburgh Travel Tips and the Fringe Festival
  3. 3Adrian's Hobbies: Rock Climbing and Bouldering
  4. 4Good Friction vs Bad Friction in Customer Experience
  5. 5UserTesting Case Study: Removing Steps Reduces Retention
  6. 6Balancing Operational Efficiency with Customer Connection

Mentioned

Adrian SwinscoeRoman TrebonKevin MeserUserTestingAndy McMillanAlex Honnold

Guests

Adrian Swinscoe

Topics in this episode

Customer experienceCustomer journey mappingCustomer experience optimizationGood friction vs. bad frictionCustomer retention vs. acquisitionPunk CXFrictionless experience designUserTesting (Andy McMillan)Value-creating interactionsOperational efficiencycustomer success playbookfrictionless customer journeygood frictionbad friction

Questions this episode answers

Why did a company's customer retention collapse after they removed steps from their signup process?

When the company streamlined their process to make it frictionless, they unknowingly eliminated the choice and decision-making steps that customers found valuable and relationship-defining. Customers could sign up easily but felt no connection to their choice, leading to poor retention despite increased signups.

What's the difference between good friction and bad friction in a customer journey?

Bad friction includes genuinely painful, effort-heavy steps that slow customers down without adding value. Good friction refers to effort required during decision-making and customization - like choosing paint color and features on a car - that customers perceive as valuable and that seal the relationship.

How should companies balance operational efficiency with maintaining customer emotional connection?

Adrian recommends doing this carefully and deliberately by analyzing where customers interact with your business, identifying real pain points that cost the business money or lose customers, reviewing data on those points, and interviewing customers to understand what works and doesn't work before removing steps.

What our scoring noted

Our reviewer’s read on each dimension, with quotes from the episode.

Insight Density

5 / 20

Roughly half the 9-minute episode is tourism small-talk and hobby chat with zero B2B value; the single substantive concept (good vs. bad friction) is covered in about 3 minutes and the practical guidance offered is entirely generic. One anecdote carries the whole intellectual load.

there's there's good and there's bad friction. And it's essential to know the difference.
you don't wanna be playing assuming that all efforts is bad friction. 'cause that could be bad for your business.

Originality

6 / 20

The good-friction/bad-friction distinction is a legitimate framing but has circulated in CX literature for years; no contrarian angle, first-principles reasoning, or counterintuitive claim is introduced. The car-customisation analogy is illustrative but adds no new thinking.

you don't wanna be playing assuming that all efforts is bad friction. 'cause that could be bad for your business.
it was the choice part of it. The effort that was required to make the choice was the thing that was delivering the value and sealing the relationship they had with their, their customers.

Guest Caliber

8 / 20

Adrian Swinscoe is a published CX author and speaker with genuine domain knowledge, but he presents as a career thought-leader rather than a practitioner who has built or scaled a CS function; his key illustration is borrowed second-hand from another executive.

I remember talking to the CEO of user testing one time, uh, when he was the former CEO of, of user testing. Andy McMillan, when he was still in post, and he told me this story

Specificity & Evidence

5 / 20

One named source (Andy McMillan / UserTesting) lends marginal credibility, but the company at the centre of the anecdote is unnamed, no metrics are quantified, and the outcome is described only as signups going 'up nicely' while retention 'fell through the floor' - no percentages, timelines, or dollar impact whatsoever.

Signups to their, to their product. Kinda went up nicely. But when it came to actually their able ability to retain customers, it fell through the floor.
I remember talking to the CEO of user testing one time, uh, when he was the former CEO of, of user testing. Andy McMillan

Conversational Craft

4 / 20

The host spends well over half the episode on lifestyle small-talk (Edinburgh tourism, a 2020 holiday, rock climbing) that yields nothing for B2B operators; the single substantive question is decent but the follow-up is a vague restatement, and no claims are challenged or probed.

if, if, if Kevin and I take a take a road trip, we want to come visit you
So, so for, for organizations who want to do this. Adrian, they want to kind of look at their, their good friction. Bad friction. How do they balance, you know, there's so much I feel like, uh, focus on operational efficiency. But how do you do that without losing the connection with your, with your customers?

Conversation analysis

Computed from the transcript - who did the talking, and the words that came up most.

Most-used words

adrian19back12friction11roman9different9trebon8cause8love8customers8swinscoe7world7customer6show5last4japan4balance4

Episode notes

Send us Fan Mail Ready to inject some punk spirit into your customer experience? In this episode of the Customer Success Playbook, Adrian Swinscoe joins Roman Trebon to explore the delicate art of reducing friction without losing that vital human touch. From the bustling cultural tapestry of Edinburgh’s Fringe Festival to personal tales of rock climbing and postponed trips to Japan, Adrian sets the stage with personality before diving into why not all friction is bad. He reveals why some “effortful” moments between a brand and its customers actually build loyalty, and how removing them in the name of efficiency can backfire spectacularly. If you’re looking to refine your customer journey without sterilizing it, this episode serves up the perfect balance of practical wisdom and a punk attitude.In a world obsessed with streamlining every process, this episode is a refreshing reminder that operational efficiency is not always the hero of customer success. Adrian Swinscoe brings a nuanced perspective: friction isn’t the bogeyman it’s often made out to be.

Full transcript

9 min

Transcribed and scored by The B2B Podcast Index.

Roman Trebon: Customer success. Welcome back to the Customer Success Playbook podcast. I'm Roman Reaugh, uh, my co-host Kevin Meser. Still out, still not with us, but, uh, we're moving on with Adrian, uh, just like we did last episode.

So, like I said, our guest is Adrian Scoe, uh, author of punk cx, author of, um, how to Wow. Speaker, author, et cetera. You've, you've seen I did the intro last show. Go back and listen to it.

So Adrian's back to talk about, uh, how to bring some serious punk spirits, uh, to your organization. But before we do, we wanna get to know Adrian a little better. We have'em on the show. So Adrian, I hope you're, uh, buckle up and ready for these really hard hitting questions.

Adrian Swinscoe: Let's do it. All right. Roman Trebon: Awesome. So, uh, if, if, if Kevin and I take a take a road trip, we want to come visit you.

I think you're in Edinburg. Yes, I am. Awesome. What's the one thing we must do when we're in Edinburgh?

What's the, what's the go-to place? We gotta see. Adrian Swinscoe: Well, apart from the castle and all the other kinda bits and pieces, 'cause it's like there's not many places in the world. It's got a castle in the center of the city.

That's kind of like, you definitely have to go and see that. But I would, I would suggest that if you come, you, you come to Edinburgh, you should plan ahead. 'cause it gets quite expensive and really busy. Mm-hmm.

But plan to come in August to come and see the Fringe Festival because it's one of the largest arts and culture and, uh, festivals in, in the world. And it's, it's. If you wanna see theater or music or comedy or kind of all sorts of other kind of performances, it says there's thousands and thousands and thousands of acts and stuff and people descend on it. And it's like, particularly in the comedy sort of space, it becomes a, a breeding ground for kind of comics trying to break into the big time.

And you see kind of the lots of different names. People come from all over the world to, to do it. So it's, it's, it's crazy, but it's brilliant. Roman Trebon: Oh, I love it.

I love our audience. You got, you got a couple months, so get those plane tickets. Look into it. Fringe festival.

That sounds awesome. I love, I love that. Adrian, yourself, if you could travel one place you've never been. Where are you going and why?

Adrian Swinscoe: Um, Japan, because of 2020, because in 2020 my wife and I had planned this big trip. We were gonna go to Tokyo for the second week of the Olympics, and then we were gonna go on to Fiji and then hang out in Fiji for a little while, and then we're gonna come back, uh, via Australia. And visit some friends and then hang out in Sydney for a little while and then come back all the way home. And that got blown up in, in 2020.

And so Japan's definitely on our list. We definitely wanna go back to Japan, so we're thinking about going for the world. Athletics championships maybe next year. Roman Trebon: Ooh.

Well, let me know because la last time you shut that, last time you trapped, uh, planned a trip to Japan, you shut down the whole world, Adrian. So let me know. Gimme a little heads up when you're going just in case something happens this time. Just will do, will do.

I'm not prepared. I'll, I'll stock up on waters and, uh, toilet paper. Alright, so when you're not researching cx, what's your hobby or pastime that helps you in one? Adrian Swinscoe: Um, the thing that I really like to do, and I've done it for, for a number of years, is I like, I like going rock climbing or bouldering just because I, like, I've, I've rock climbed for a, a long time.

Both, I mean, different parts of the world, kind of outdoors, indoors, all these and different sort of like seasons and stuff, but just going to the rock climbing gym and just doing a bunch of routines or trying a whole bunch of kind of problems. It's brilliant, it's great exercise, but it's also quite meditative because it's all about balance and movement and focus and all these different things. So it becomes a bit like yoga sort of thing. You can go off and get your exercise, but then do this kind of thing and you come out feeling everything is, you know, everything just falls outta your mind'cause it requires kinda focus.

So it's a, it's a really great way to, um, unwind. But unfortunately I haven't done it for a very while because I've been dealing with some historical. Got like some back injury stuff. There's historical stuff, and so I'm out until September time, but hopefully, I'm really looking forward to getting back into it.

Roman Trebon: That'd be awesome. You, you're not one of those three climbers, right? I'm not gonna see up the side of a mountain with any ropes. Right?

You have a rope, you're, you're locked in and good to go. Adrian Swinscoe: I am when bouldering is all low levels, so you can jump off onto mats. I have nothing like kind of Alex Honnold that he is a, he is a, he is a, a. An incredible kinda human being in terms of what he does.

But no, I'm tied to a rope that even tied to a rope is dangerous enough. But when you can climb just with shoes and short bag, that's kind of different level, man. Roman Trebon: Crazy. I'm scared of heights.

I see those guys do. I can't even watch the videos, Adrian. I, I, I get freaked out just watching it. But what they do is amazing.

Awesome. Thanks for sharing that. I think it's time for us to get into our one big question. So, so Adrian, uh, many companies, they wanna reduce customer friction, right?

Fewer steps, less friction, easier to get through, et cetera. But how, how do companies do that without stripping out the, the human or emotional connection that really helps us get tied to the brand? Adrian Swinscoe: So I think the thing that we need to be, we need to, first of all, we need to recognize there's, there's good and there's bad friction. And it's essential to know the difference.

And I remember, so I'll, to illustrate this, I'll, I'll, I'll. I'll give you an example. I remember talking to the CEO of user testing one time, uh, when he was the former CEO of, of user testing. Andy McMillan, when he was still in post, and he told me this story about a company that, um, that they worked with that was infused by this idea about creating this frictionless, kind of like customer experience.

And they ended up taking all these different kinda bits out and out of the process and streamlining it and things Now. Here's what happened. Signups to their, to their product. Kinda went up nicely.

But when it came to actually their able ability to retain customers, it fell through the floor. 'cause and when they can, when they stopped and they thought about this and that,'cause that was alarming to them, and they were like, oh, it's easier for people to sign up, but we're actually not keeping customers. So it's like, oh, what have we done? Have we actually built this boat?

We were trying to sell it with a hole in the bottom of it. But when they looked into it and they spoke to their customers, what they realized was all of the steps that they'd taken out that they assumed were effort. Full, as it were, were the things that were. The word value defining for the relationship they have with their customers.

So like imagine you go into a, um, like say, say you like choosing a car or something and you say, I want this car and I want this, this paint work and this finish and this drive, and all these different sort of things. Um. What they were doing is they were taking all these different things out and it was almost becoming automatic, like fixed choices as it were. And actually what they found out was actually it was the choice part of it.

The effort that was required to make the choice was the thing that was delivering the value and sealing the relationship they had with their, their customers. And so what they went, they were like, oh, horror and then basically rewound everything that they did to try and. Almost put themselves back to where they were because what they'd done by the whole friction, uh, taking all these steps out, they'd actually eliminated all the value making steps that they had in it. So it's a really important.

To, to understand what parts of your process are good friction and what parts of the process are bad friction. And you need to know the difference. 'cause you don't wanna be playing assuming that all efforts is bad friction. 'cause that could be bad for your business.

Roman Trebon: Yeah, no, I love that. I love that story. Uh, it's, it's amazing, right? You take all that out and then your clients are leaving through the back door without even, uh, without even thinking about it, right?

So, so for, for organizations who want to do this. Adrian, they want to kind of look at their, their good friction. Bad friction. How do they balance, you know, there's so much I feel like, uh, focus on operational efficiency.

Yeah. But how do you do that without losing the connection with your, with your customers? Adrian Swinscoe: It's a really big question and I, I, I, you know, and I. Who don't have time for me to write well, to speak out an essay, an essay on this book.

So I, I'd say two, like two things. Yeah. I think you need to do it carefully, carefully, and deliberately. And you have to think about where the customer's kinda journey and where they interact with you and what's the kinda right balance of human and, and and tech and what, what, what, what are things are, are real kinda like pain points that are costing you the costing, uh, the business in terms of operational kind of cost or maybe kind of too much effort that you're losing customers at those kind of points.

And then you just need to. Again, go back to the data thing that we talked about on Monday. We need to go get into the data, then think to see about what people are saying about all these different sort of points. And then if it needs to be, get out and talk to people about what works and what doesn't kinda work.

Hear are those stories. Gonna listen to those stories, kind of like absorb those stories. 'cause if you only, if you do that carefully and deliberately, then are, are you gonna get a real sense of what works and what doesn't work and why you should. What you should be fixing, what you should be leaving alone.

Roman Trebon: Yeah. No, I love it. I love it. Awesome stuff, Adrian.

Really appreciate it. Big takeaways, uh, really make sure you balance, understand the, your customers good friction, bad friction, uh, simplify, but, you know, maybe don't, don't, don't over, uh, engineer it or, or sanitize it, right. So, absolutely. Adrian, you're gonna come back for a third show, right?

I, we haven't scared way yet. Yes, I'm awesome. Awesome. That's awesome.

For our audience, I hope you enjoyed the show. Again, make sure you subscribe so you know, when our new shows come out, like it, give us a rating comment that really helps us, uh, get, uh, our show out to more professionals in the customer success world. As always, we really appreciate you listening and keep on playing.

Related episodes across the Index

Other episodes covering the same guests and topics, from across The B2B Podcast Index.

  • Why a $1.2B exit felt like his biggest failure, and the customer-obsession thesis behind AgencyThe GTMnow Podcast · on Customer retention vs. acquisition86 / 100
  • How B2B Marketers Use Customer Marketing for ExpansionB2B Marketing with Fexingo · on Customer journey mapping83 / 100
  • How Mollie's is Running Hospitality Like a High Street Retailer - With Matt Bell, Mollie's MotelsPillow Talk Sessions · on Operational efficiency78 / 100
  • 39: How sales and marketing can grow together: Insights from Braze Chief Revenue Officer Ed McDonnellMarketing Beyond with Alan B. Hart · on Customer journey mapping78 / 100
  • Ep 553 Why 17.5% of Owners Are Burnt Out and Want to SellBuilt to Sell Radio · on Customer journey mapping77 / 100
  • Managed Services: The Engine Powering B2B LoyaltyBeyond the Transaction · on Customer experience76 / 100

More from The Customer Success Playbook

All episodes →
  • Customer Success Playbook - Final Episode with Kevin and Roman31 / 100
  • Customer Success Playbook Podcast S3 E72 - Adrian Swinscoe - Enhancing Customer Experience with AI55 / 100
  • Customer Success Playbook Podcast S3 E70 - Adrian Swinscoe - Data and Customer Storytelling74 / 100
  • Customer Success Playbook S3 E69 - Gayle Gorvett - Scaling AI Governance Without Killing Innovation65 / 100
  • Customer Success Playbook S3 E68 - Gayle Gorvett - Who's Liable When AI Goes Wrong?56 / 100
Explore the best B2B Customer Success podcasts →
All The Customer Success Playbook episodes →