The B2B Podcast Index
Index
All categories
MarketingSalesSaaSFinanceHROpsLeadershipCustomer SuccessAI & DataProductStartups & FoundersRevOpsEngineering & DevTools
MethodologySubmit
Best of:MarketingSalesSaaSFinanceHROpsLeadershipCustomer SuccessAI & DataProductStartups & FoundersRevOpsEngineering & DevTools
An independent project byFame
SearchBest episodesGuestsInsightsMethodologySubmit a podcast
#5991#HRSucks33.0 / 100Get badge
← The Index
#HRSucks artwork
HR▲35 this period

#HRSucks

Hosted by George Cagle

Listed under Business

All things HR related.

2 episodes · latest 2019-05-19 · ~15 min/episode

Rank

#5991

Substance

33.0

/ 100

Breakdown

Scored 2026-08
Updated monthly

HR rank

#366 of 379

Best B2B HR Podcasts →

Across the index

#5991 of 6203

Substance

Top 97%

outscores 3% of the index

Why it scores where it does

#HRSucks ranks #5991 on The B2B Podcast Index with a substance score of 33.0 out of 100, scored across 2 recent episodes. It scores highest on insight density and originality. The episode contains a few actionable principles (praise publicly, criticize privately; development prevents stagnation) but largely consists of rambling, throat-clearing, and self-aware admissions of lack of structure. The host explicitly states 'future episodes will not be just me rambling on,' confirming this episode is mostly filler. Substantive takeaways are sparse and obvious to any HR operator.

The five-dimension breakdown

Averaged across 2 recently scored episodes, with cited evidence.

Insight Density

8.0 / 20

The episode contains a few actionable principles (praise publicly, criticize privately; development prevents stagnation) but largely consists of rambling, throat-clearing, and self-aware admissions of lack of structure. The host explicitly states 'future episodes will not be just me rambling on,' confirming this episode is mostly filler. Substantive takeaways are sparse and obvious to any HR operator.

“future episodes will not be just me rambling on”

“always praise in public, anytime you have the option or the opportunity, and always Criticize or provide feedback in private”

Originality

7.0 / 20

The advice offered is standard HR orthodoxy: praise publicly, criticize privately; develop people to retain them; build relationships; set expectations. These are foundational, widely-circulated principles with no contrarian angle, first-principles thinking, or fresh perspective. The framing of 'HR sucks' is attention-grabbing but not substantively original.

“always praise in public, anytime you have the option or the opportunity, and always Criticize or provide feedback in private”

“what if we don't spend the time and the energy and the effort training and developing our Workforce and our people, and they stay, and they stay with our company”

Guest Caliber

5.5 / 20

This is a solo episode with no guests. The host appears to be an HR practitioner or operations manager (references working in a factory setting, managing supervisors), but provides no credentials, track record, scale of operation managed, or evidence of exceptional expertise. A solo founder rambling is not a substitute for substantive guest expertise.

“Here I am, I'm driving to work”

“this is introductory to HR Sucks podcast”

Specificity & Evidence

6.5 / 20

Almost no concrete examples, metrics, or named case studies. The host mentions working at a factory, operating on four 10-hour days, and references generic employee categories ('frequent flyers,' 'drama llamas') but provides zero specific situations, dollar figures, timelines, or companies. Even the promised 'can't make it up' stories are explicitly withheld to protect privacy.

“I will never uh, share specifics about the specific place or job or company or certainly people that I'm interacting with”

“maintain privacy of whoever it is the story might be about”

Conversational Craft

6.0 / 20

No conversation occurs; this is an extended monologue with no guest, no follow-ups, no pushback, and no interviewing. The host frequently loses focus (acknowledges a 'wonky transition' due to phone notifications, goes on tangents about TV and fantasy books), self-corrects, and lacks structure. There is no craft or intentional question design - only stream-of-consciousness rambling.

“So uh, here I am, I'm driving to work”

“So sorry about the wonky transition”

Standout episodes

  • HR Sucks Episode 1

    2019-05-17

    35
  • Expectations

    2019-05-19

    31

Rank over time

2 periods tracked.

Episodes

2 scored on substance.

  • Expectations

    2019-05-19 · 15 min

    31 / 100
  • HR Sucks Episode 1

    2019-05-17 · 16 min

    35 / 100

Frequently asked

What is #HRSucks's substance score?
#HRSucks scores 33.0 out of 100 for substance and ranks #5991 on The B2B Podcast Index. That puts it ahead of 3% of the B2B podcasts we rank and #366 of 379 in HR. The score reflects insight density, originality, guest caliber, specificity and conversational craft across recent episodes - not downloads.
Is #HRSucks worth listening to?
#HRSucks is ranked on The B2B Podcast Index with a substance score of 33.0/100. See the five-dimension breakdown above to judge whether it fits what you're after.
Who hosts #HRSucks?
#HRSucks is hosted by George Cagle.
How often does #HRSucks publish?
#HRSucks has 2 episodes, released its most recent episode on 2019-05-19.
Which #HRSucks episode should I start with?
Our highest-scoring recent episode is "HR Sucks Episode 1" (35/100) - a good place to start.

Show off your #366 rank in HR

Add this badge to your site - it links back here and updates automatically as you rank.

Ranked #366 on The B2B Podcast Index
Embed code
<a href="https://index.fame.so/show/hrsucks" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
  <img src="https://index.fame.so/badge/hrsucks/badge.svg" alt="Ranked #366 on The B2B Podcast Index" width="360" height="136" />
</a>
Markdown & other formats →

Track #HRSucks's rank

Get an email whenever this show moves up or down the Index. Monthly at most, no spam.

Listen / subscribe:WebsiteSpotifyRSS

Topics this show covers

The themes that come up most across this show's episodes.

Leadership development · 2Expectation-setting in managementCorrective action and coaching conversationsFeedback communicationManufacturing operations and team managementPassive-aggressive workplace dynamicsUpward communication and managing your bossEmployee behavior observation and gap managementHR policy and workplace conduct standardsEmployee accountabilityworkplace cultureHR as business partnerworkplace relationshipsTurnover reductionPublic praise vs. private criticismEmployee training and developmentExpectation-setting in HRFour-day work week implementations

More HR podcasts

See all →
  • People Managing People

    David Rice

    84.8
  • Masters of Automation

    Alp Uguray

    81.6
  • Digital HR Leaders with David Green

    David Green

    78.0
  • Hidden Layers

    KUNGFU.AI

    77.8
  • “HR Heretics”

    HR Heretics

    76.6
  • unSILOed with Greg LaBlanc

    Greg La Blanc

    76.6

Similar shows

Podcasts that dig into the same topics.

  • Your Work Friends

    Mel Plett & Francesca Ranieri

  • Humanity At Scale: Redefining Leadership

    Bruce Temkin

    77.4
  • Voice Activated: Tuning Employee Insights At Work

    Sean Fitzpatrick

    69.0
  • Leadership BITES

    Guy Bloom | Living Brave Leadership

    68.8
  • Success Leaves Clues with Robin Bailey and Al McDonald

    A Starting with One Podcast

    64.2
  • Diagnosing The Workplace: Not Just An HR Podcast

    Roman 3

    62.0