
Hosted by Robin Choy
Learn from the best recruiting leaders. themodernrecruiter.substack.com
78 episodes · publishes fortnightly · latest 2024-09-26 · ~33 min/episode
Rank
#1944
Substance
67.0
/ 100
Breakdown
Scored 2026-07
Updated monthly
Across the index
#1944 of 6183
Substance
Top 31%
outscores 69% of the index
The Modern Recruiter ranks #1944 on The B2B Podcast Index with a substance score of 67.0 out of 100, scored across 1 recent episode. It scores highest on guest caliber and specificity & evidence. Mena is a genuine 20-year practitioner who built his own firm, staffed billion-dollar government programs, and runs a 179-episode podcast - real operator credibility in a specific niche. However, Select Source Solutions is a small firm and his expertise is narrow (govcon staffing), limiting broad B2B relevance.
Averaged across 1 recently scored episode, with cited evidence.
The episode is predominantly biographical narrative with occasional useful takeaways buried in anecdote. Actionable insights exist (1% LinkedIn posting stat, reframing from helping everyone to helping the right candidate, refusing sales training as a costly mistake, virtual events as BD) but they appear infrequently and are rarely developed with depth.
“only 1% of the active population on LinkedIn actually post something”
“one of the biggest decisions that impacted my career and probably took away millions of dollars of revenue that I could have made sooner is I kept on saying no to sales training”
Most frameworks here are well-worn recruiter career advice: find a niche, surround yourself with better people, intrinsic motivation matters, go back to basics. The 'spotlight others to have it shine back on you' content insight is moderately fresh, and the govcon margin dynamics add minor novelty, but there is little genuinely contrarian or first-principles thinking.
“putting the spotlight on somebody else in turn will always put the spotlight back on you”
“the government contracting space, typically the lowest bidder is the one that wins the work”
Mena is a genuine 20-year practitioner who built his own firm, staffed billion-dollar government programs, and runs a 179-episode podcast - real operator credibility in a specific niche. However, Select Source Solutions is a small firm and his expertise is narrow (govcon staffing), limiting broad B2B relevance.
“I focus on government contracting... I've had a direct impact in over a billion dollars worth of government contracts”
“shortly after that, looking at the next year, I was like on that list every single week. Typically like one to three”
The episode contains a reasonable sprinkling of concrete numbers - the $556M program, 650 virtual event signups, 26,000 DC-metro recruiters, 80/20 consulting split - which elevate it above pure abstraction. However, many figures are approximate and the govcon mechanics, while specific, are explained at a surface level without hard sourcing.
“took a vacation after just staffing up $556 million program”
“fast forward by the end of the week it was like 650 and I was like, what the hell's going on”
The host sets a warm tone and uses a clever structural device (borrowing the guest's own three questions), and does probe on company revenue mix and career transitions. However, he frequently answers his own questions, asks multi-part open-ended prompts that let the guest drift, and never meaningfully challenges any claim or pushes for harder evidence.
“So what's the split today with kind of more the consulting and more the direct placement?”
“What would you say if you had the opportunity to talk to your younger self?”
First period on the Index - history builds from here.
1 scored on substance · 60 tracked in total.
Add this badge to your site - it links back here and updates automatically as you rank.
<a href="https://index.fame.so/show/the-modern-recruiter" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
<img src="https://index.fame.so/badge/the-modern-recruiter/badge.svg" alt="Ranked #86 on The B2B Podcast Index" width="360" height="136" />
</a>Track The Modern Recruiter's rank
Get an email whenever this show moves up or down the Index. Monthly at most, no spam.
The themes that come up most across this show's episodes.
Podcasts that dig into the same topics.