
Hosted by Michael Stelzner, Social Media Examiner
Get expert opinions on the latest social media marketing news, from Social Media Examiner. This show shares only the news you need to know. You’ll gain quick insight that could provide you a competitive advantage. Watch the live show at SocialMediaExaminer.com/liveshow
397 episodes · publishes weekly · latest 2026-02-05 · ~21 min/episode
Rank
#4413
Substance
53.0
/ 100
Breakdown
Scored 2026-07
Updated monthly
Across the index
#4413 of 6186
Substance
Top 71%
outscores 29% of the index
Social Media Marketing Talk Show ranks #4413 on The B2B Podcast Index with a substance score of 53.0 out of 100, scored across 1 recent episode. It scores highest on guest caliber and insight density. Chelsea Peitz is a legitimate practitioner and published author focused on social media for sales professionals, giving her real-world credibility. However, she repeatedly admits she hasn't used the features under discussion (trial reels, several Edits app updates), and her expertise skews toward personal branding coaching rather than B2B operations at scale.
Averaged across 1 recently scored episode, with cited evidence.
The episode is primarily a feature-announcement rundown with light tactical commentary. There are occasional mildly useful observations (e.g., sequencing an early-access reel before a trial reel as a 'double dip'), but the bulk of airtime is feature description, speculation about unreleased updates, and two full ad breaks that eat into the 22-minute runtime.
“this may be, uh, what they had in mind, but it's kind of like a double dip, if you will”
“if this gets adopted, this is where the more aligned your content is with a single topic, the more likely you are to have people coming back over and over and over again”
The thinking stays squarely on the surface of each feature with no first-principles or contrarian angles. The most original moment is the 'double dip' sequencing idea; everything else - FOMO psychology, 'tell people about something they can't have' - is well-worn marketing convention.
“you know what the best way to market something is tell somebody about something they can't have yet”
“as soon as we say the word share, meta will kill our reach on that story”
Chelsea Peitz is a legitimate practitioner and published author focused on social media for sales professionals, giving her real-world credibility. However, she repeatedly admits she hasn't used the features under discussion (trial reels, several Edits app updates), and her expertise skews toward personal branding coaching rather than B2B operations at scale.
“You know what? I've honestly never used the trial reels.”
“I don't have these yet, so again, I'm hopeful that I will get them soon”
Concrete evidence is nearly absent: no campaign metrics, no client results, no named brand examples. The one data point offered ('12 million views') is unattributed ('a guy' at 'a conference'). Most claims about feature behavior are speculative because the features haven't fully rolled out yet.
“he had one that got like 12 million views or, I don't know, something just insane”
“I've only noticed that it brings it down to 20 and I feel like that's still really loud if I'm talking”
The host does generate some genuine follow-up (catching the ambiguity about uploading 'the same reel twice' and pressing for clarification), and the rapport is natural rather than scripted-PR. However, virtually no claims are challenged, speculative statements pass without scrutiny, and the conversation often drifts into mutual agreement and anecdote rather than productive interrogation.
“Oh, two separate reels. Okay. I thought you meant uploading the same video two different times.”
“Come on, Adam M. Let's hear your thoughts.”
First period on the Index - history builds from here.
1 scored on substance · 60 tracked in total.
Add this badge to your site - it links back here and updates automatically as you rank.
<a href="https://index.fame.so/show/social-media-marketing-talk-show" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
<img src="https://index.fame.so/badge/social-media-marketing-talk-show/badge.svg" alt="Ranked #651 on The B2B Podcast Index" width="360" height="136" />
</a>Track Social Media Marketing Talk Show's rank
Get an email whenever this show moves up or down the Index. Monthly at most, no spam.
The themes that come up most across this show's episodes.