The B2B Podcast Index
Index
All categories
MarketingSalesSaaSFinanceHROpsLeadershipCustomer SuccessAI & DataProductStartups & FoundersRevOpsEngineering & DevTools
MethodologySubmit
Best of:MarketingSalesSaaSFinanceHROpsLeadershipCustomer SuccessAI & DataProductStartups & FoundersRevOpsEngineering & DevTools
An independent project byFame
SearchBest episodesGuestsInsightsMethodologySubmit a podcast
Index/Marketing/Shiny New Clients!
Shiny New Clients! artwork

The 2026 Instagram Algorithm Update (and the ONLY part that matters)

Shiny New Clients! · 2026-04-06 · 13 min

0:00--:--

Key moments - from our scoring

Substance score

46 / 100

Five dimensions, 20 points each

Insight Density12 / 20
Originality9 / 20
Guest Caliber8 / 20
Specificity & Evidence10 / 20
Conversational Craft7 / 20

Jenna Harding, who has spent eight years helping business owners grow and acquire clients on Instagram, cuts through 2026 algorithm noise by identifying one metric that has remained constant: getting people to touch your posts. The new algorithm specifically rewards the share/paper airplane button, signaling Meta's focus on creating community and conversation across its ecosystem (Instagram, Messenger, WhatsApp). Harding's most-viewed content series - B-roll Reels ideas - succeeds precisely because followers share these tips across their personal and business accounts, triggering algorithmic amplification. She introduces the concept of engagement attractors and social currency, drawing on Jonah Berger's viral content research. Posts gain traction by eliciting emotional responses (joy, anger, inspiration), providing information followers are passionate about sharing, or explicitly inviting shares ("Share this with someone who..."). Featured alumna Molly Donlan, a Reiki master and author in Harding's Magic Marketing Machine program, shares how this strategy grew her Instagram following to 250,000+ and her email list to 17,000. B2B operators and content creators will benefit from concrete tactics: focus on social currency, emotional drivers, and shareability rather than chasing algorithm updates.

Key takeaways

  • →The 2026 Instagram algorithm prioritizes shares (especially via direct message) over all other engagement signals, making the share button the single metric that matters most.
  • →Content succeeds when it provides social currency - giving followers a reason to share because it makes them look good, whether through advocacy, humor, or belonging to a community.
  • →Posts need emotional drivers (joy, anger, inspiration, curiosity) to be shared; even practical content like recipes or B-roll ideas go viral when paired with emotional resonance or useful information followers want to spread.
  • →Creating content for your ideal client's needs rather than generic growth tactics ensures followers are motivated to share because the content actually matters to them.
  • →Start with the goal of getting five shares per week to practice building shareability into every post, which trains the algorithm to show your content to more people.

Guests

Molly Donlan

Topics in this episode

Magic Marketing MachineInstagram algorithm 2026engagement attractorssocial currencypaper airplane/share buttonB-roll Reels ideasJonah Berger viral content frameworkemotional drivers in contentMeta ecosystem (Instagram, Messenger, WhatsApp)shareability metrics

Questions this episode answers

What does the 2026 Instagram algorithm actually prioritize?

The 2026 update prioritizes shares (the paper airplane/send button), especially when content is shared to direct messages. This signals Meta's push toward creating conversation and community across its ecosystem including WhatsApp, Messenger, and Instagram DMs.

Why does Jenna Harding's B-roll Reels ideas series get the most views and shares?

Followers share the B-roll ideas to their own accounts (personal and business) to remember them later, creating inflated share counts that signal to the algorithm the post is valuable, triggering wider distribution.

What is social currency and how does it make content shareable?

Social currency is the benefit followers get from sharing - whether standing up for causes they believe in, making friends laugh, or being associated with helpful information. Posts with high social currency get shared more because sharing them makes the sharer look good.

What types of content get people to hit the share button?

Emotional content (jokes, inspiring stories, political/social causes), useful information followers are passionate about spreading, and posts that explicitly invite shares ("Share this with someone who...") consistently drive the share engagement the algorithm rewards.

How did Molly Donlan grow her Instagram to 250,000 followers and fill her training program?

By joining Magic Marketing Machine and learning to create content that combined sales skills with personality-driven, nurturing content rather than just growth tactics, eventually growing her email list to 17,000 and creating waitlists over 1,800 people long.

What our scoring noted

Our reviewer’s read on each dimension, with quotes from the episode.

Insight Density

12 / 20

The episode contains some actionable insights about Instagram's 2026 algorithm prioritizing shares and DMs, plus the social currency framework from Jonah Berger. However, these core ideas are presented with significant filler, repetition, and obvious advice (e.g., 'create content people care about'). The Molly testimonial adds no algorithmic insight, just sales promotion.

None of the updates ever actually matter as long as you know one thing and that thing is get people to touch your posts.
The new Instagram algorithm in 2026 really wants people tapping the paper airplane and sharing your content amongst each other.

Originality

9 / 20

The core claim - that algorithm updates don't matter, only engagement does - is fairly standard industry wisdom. The social currency framework is borrowed explicitly from Jonah Berger's existing work. The share-button optimization angle is a minor tactical twist but not truly contrarian or fresh thinking for a 2026 'update' framed as novel.

None of the updates ever actually matter as long as you know one thing
Jonah Berger talks about this in his book all about what makes content go viral.

Guest Caliber

8 / 20

Molly Donlan is presented as a success story from Jenna's program, but her guest segment is a pre-recorded testimonial, not a true conversation or interview. She is positioned as a buyer of Jenna's service, not a peer operator or expert contributing unique insight. No push-back, no debate, pure endorsement.

I joined MMM years ago because even though I had a large following over on TikTok, I was struggling to convert them to sales.
And that is all thanks to everything that I learned in MMM from Jenna and her team. I'd recommend MMM to anyone

Specificity & Evidence

10 / 20

The episode includes a few concrete details: Molly's 75-person launch, 250k followers, 17k email subscribers, 1800-person waitlist. The B-roll Reels series and share observation are specific to Jenna's own account. However, most tactical advice is generic (e.g., 'create shareable content'), and no data on actual algorithm behavior, engagement rates, or reach multipliers are provided.

I had 75 people join.
My email list has grown from like I had like 3,000 subscribers to 17,000 subscribers.

Conversational Craft

7 / 20

This is largely a monologue by Jenna with zero pushback or critical questioning. The Molly segment is a one-way testimonial read aloud. Jenna asks rhetorical questions ('How am I supposed to just create shareable content?') but immediately answers them herself. There is no guest interaction, no challenge to claims, no exploratory dialogue.

And as a directive, that might have you going in your head right now, like, well, how the heck am I supposed to do that? How am I supposed to just create shareable content?
So one thing I like to think about is social currency

Conversation analysis

Computed from the transcript - who did the talking, and the words that came up most.

Most-used words

content21post17instagram12share11creating9roll8algorithm7making7jenna6sharing6ideas6learned6followers6viral6recipe6clients5

Episode notes

Find out the major change that determines if your posts are shown to more people, and 3 ways to incorporate it into your content strategy. Plus, hear my take on the one - only - thing you really need to know about the Instagram algorithm, as someone who has worked in social media management for 8+ years. We break down how the Instagram algorithm actually works in 2026 (and why most updates don’t matter nearly as much as you think). If you’ve been stressing about low reach, declining engagement, or trying to “keep up” with every new feature, this episode will simplify everything. Inside this episode, you’ll learn how to create content people actually want to share, how to use “engagement attractors” to increase Instagram reach, and how to build a content strategy that consistently gets your posts in front of new audiences - without chasing every algorithm update. Get clients from Instagram inside Magic Marketing Machine! Watch a FREE masterclass called “How To Get Clients From Instagram (without wasting hours glued to your phone)" Music by Jordan Wood Hosted by Jenna Harding (Warriner), Creator of Magic Marketing Machine Get clients from Instagram!

Full transcript

13 min

Transcribed and scored by The B2B Podcast Index.

Jenna Harding That pesky Instagram algorithm just changed again in 2026. Here's what you need to know so you can keep getting your content in front of ideal clients. and someone who has helped business owners grow on Instagram and get clients from their posts for, I don't know, eight years or something. I don't know how long I've been doing this a long time, Enough time to see a lot of my clients be brand new business owners and build six figure businesses mostly credited to The clients they're getting on Instagram.

I've been in this game a long time and I do have one opinion about the Instagram algorithm that I hold firm to. And ironically, it is this. None of the updates ever actually matter as long as you know one thing and that thing is get people to touch your posts. all my time and in all the updates and all the iterations of this app, none of that has changed.

We're always creating content that interests our ideal ideal client. We're doing research to figure out what they need to hear from us. And then we're making content based on what they're going through and what they need, And then we're building every single post to be touched. In my program, Magic Marketing Machine, we call this using engagement attractors.

instead of just creating a post and hoping people interact with it, you're building every post to be touched. And that is one thing that this new update really wants you to do, but they don't want any old engagements. They want a very specific one. the new Instagram algorithm in 2026, really wants people tapping the paper airplane and sharing your content amongst each other.

In Instagram's eyes, this means creating community, creating conversation. You might remember last year they had a really strong push towards direct messages. And remember also Meta owns WhatsApp. like WhatsApp, Messenger, Instagram DMs, they really doubled down on that last year and they wanted people having conversations.

Which means you need to make content that makes people want to share it. And as a directive, that might have you going in your head right now, like, well, how the heck am I supposed to do that? How am I supposed to just create shareable content? so I'll give you a couple of ideas for that right now.

But when I learned this, it made something else make perfect sense. So If you came to this podcast because you know me from Instagram where I am at Jenna's Paige page with an I, you probably have seen my B-roll Reels ideas series. It is my most popular series. I get the most views when I give B-roll ideas to business owners and most of my followers come from my B-roll Reels ideas.

Now I use the strategy I teach, which means I can't just post B-roll real ideas. here for clients, so I also have have my nurture and my sales content. But the B-roll reels ones get the most views and they always get the And I recently noticed they get shared a ton. And I wonder to myself, I'm giving a goofy B-roll reel idea Who is sharing these?

Like literally who is sharing these? I was kind of baffled by it. So I made a post saying, hey, who's sharing these? Like, where are these going?

Where are you sending me? I was like making a joke about it. Mom, dark in here, mom. And then in the comments, my followers all told me that a lot of my followers, because they have businesses, they have a personal account and a business account.

and are sending the B-Roll Reels ideas to their other accounts so that they remember to make them. Which means I have all these inflated shares and then the algorithm sees people are sharing the post and then the algorithm sends that post to more people because it's getting the exact engagement that the new algorithm wants it to have. So they have a priority on shares, especially post being shared to the direct messages. And that is probably a big part of why my B-roll Reels series is always my thing that gets the most views.

because it has all of those shares. Fascinating stuff, right? Let's talk about you. What can you say that's going to get people hitting the little paper airplane button?

That's what it is, right? It just looks like a little triangle, but I think it's a paper airplane that's why it indicates send. on Instagram. So what can you be posting that gets people Jenna Warriner I'm going to give you three options for shareable content that you can make right now that will work for your specific business.

But first, I have a guest recording here from one of my alumni from Magic Marketing Machine, Molly Donlan, who wants to tell you a quick story. Then we'll come back and talk about what you're going to post this week. Jenna Warriner Hi, my name's Molly Donlan. I'm a Reiki master teacher and author of mundane magic.

And I help people add more magic into their everyday lives using a blend of science and spirituality. I joined MMM years ago because even though I had a large following over on TikTok, I was struggling to convert them to sales. I had a Reiki training program that... getting eight people into was like pulling teeth.

I just did not know how to sell. I only knew how to make growth content. And additionally, I only knew how to make growth content on TikTok. I really struggled with Instagram as a platform, knowing what to post, when to post.

I found it just a slog. I really, really struggled with it. I hated writing captions. I hated creating videos.

I just, it was not my jam. It was not my thing. And through MMM, I really learned so much of the skills that I use today. I learned how to sell my services.

I learned how to enjoy making content again. I learned how to put my personality into my content again. I feel like when I was grinding out content and not able to connect with people, nurture people, create sales, I was just like a textbook. I really just felt like I was churning out content and for what?

I really wasn't getting that reciprocity back and I wasn't building a community. After MMM, about four months after I joined MMM or so, I joined at the end of March 2022 and in August 2022, I had my first launch since joining the program and I had 75 people join. I know. Wild.

And it felt fun. It felt easy. It felt exciting. ⁓ Now it's been almost four years.

I'm still enrolled in MMM and I have over a quarter of a million followers on Instagram. My email list has grown from like I had like 3,000 subscribers to 17,000 subscribers. ⁓ My training in the past couple of years has sold out within literally minutes. I have a wait list that is over 1800 people long and I just really feel excited about creating content again.

⁓ Being on Instagram has allowed me to really meet some of my wildest dreams like publishing a book, having a number one podcast ⁓ and ultimately fostering a community where I really, really feel like I'm making a difference in the world. And that is all thanks to everything that I learned in MMM from Jenna and her team. I'd recommend MMM to anyone who is looking to grow a business, who is looking to fall in love with creating content. ⁓ I think it can be really easy when we're pulling tips and tricks from everywhere to think we have to do everything.

And one thing that MMM really helped me find is how to do my thing. how to do it Molly's way, how to really enjoy creating content and create content that connects and feels authentic to me. And I think that's really the thing that sets MMM apart. So, highly recommend.

You join MMM. Okay. Love you. Bye.

Jenna Harding So one thing I like to think about is social currency, when you create a post that By sharing it, give someone social currency, they're more likely to share it, especially to their stories. Think about like political advocacy or any causes that you stand by. Maybe it's like Pride Month and an account I follow makes a really nice Pride post. That's something that I care about.

So I'm going to hit the paper airplane. I'm going to share it to my stories because I now get the social currency of standing up for this cause that I believe in in my stories. another really simple example of this is when you share a joke with a friend, right? You share a meme or like a funny video that's going to make people laugh.

you kind inherit that laugh, right? If you saw a meme that's gonna make your friend Susan laugh, so you send that to Susan and she laughs and then she writes back to you, ha ha, you know me so well. Now you have social currency. Jonah Berger talks about this in his book all about what makes content go viral.

It always elicits an emotional reaction. So whether you're making people angry or making them happy or making them sad, any viral posts has an emotional driver. even take like a viral cookie recipe. my gosh.

Remember that viral cookie recipe where the person went to a restaurant. don't know if it's a true story, but they went to this fancy restaurant in the restaurant. and they asked their server if they can have a copy of the recipe for the chocolate chip cookie that they had because it was so good and the server gave it to them. And then there was a $10,000 charge on their bill.

because they had charged them $10,000 for this cookie recipe. So then the person took that recipe and spread it wide and gave it to everybody and shared it with everyone. And it has this emotional driver because it has this story behind it. But even a delicious mouth-watering photo of a cookie is gonna make us share that recipe because of that like visceral feeling that that comfort food is giving us.

Even that is still an emotional response in its own way. Isn't that neat? I'm such a nerd for it. So remember earlier I was talking about how your content needs to be for your people.

Think about this. Another thing that gets spread is information information that we're passionate that needs to be spread, but it can't be you that's passionate. It needs to be your ideal client is passionate. Your followers need to be passionate about the spread of this information not.

use. got to put yourself in their shoes. What would they share with people or heck just make a post that says share this with someone who blah blah blah blah blah. You know we know in another way that goes viral all the time.

I see these all the time is like because I follow a lot of like nature and adventure accounts and it'll be a really adventurous looking photo of a mountain and it'll be like Share this to someone who you want to go here with, right? So everyone's going to share it. The algorithm sees that they're being shared. It shows it to more people.

It takes off. The ball rolls. The post goes viral. What can you post?

What can you post that can get shared this week? What if you only had one job and it is to get five shares? Five shares this week. Why don't we just start aiming with that?

And then you can celebrate every single winch, celebrate every single share. And you'll be practicing this muscle of creating content that really truly interests your followers so much so that they want to spread it for you. Have a beautiful, wonderful, fabulous freaking week. Go get views and build your business.

More from Shiny New Clients!

All episodes →
  • Client Retention Strategies: Tips to keep your clients, longer (feat. Eric Lalonde, CEO of WriteUpp)52 / 100
  • Are Instagram courses worth it?44 / 100
  • The messaging mistake new business owners make on social media (i'm guilty too)56 / 100
  • Write An "I Help" Statement That Sticks With People (How to Explain What You Do)55 / 100
  • Local Marketing Strategies (and how to reach local audiences on Instagram)53 / 100
Explore the best B2B Marketing podcasts →
All Shiny New Clients! episodes →