
Hosted by Men of Color in Educational Leadership
Next Man Up amplifies the voices and experiences of men of color in educational leadership. Hosted by Kareem Thomas, the podcast explores the triumphs, challenges, and pivotal moments that shape leaders breaking barriers and driving systemic change in education.
22 episodes · publishes fortnightly · latest 2026-07-02 · ~36 min/episode
Rank
#4989
Substance
48.0
/ 100
Breakdown
Scored 2026-07
Updated monthly
Across the index
#4989 of 6183
Substance
Top 81%
outscores 19% of the index
Next Man Up: An MCEL Podcast ranks #4989 on The B2B Podcast Index with a substance score of 48.0 out of 100, scored across 1 recent episode. It scores highest on guest caliber and insight density. Both guests are genuine practitioners with lived principal and district-leadership experience - one candidly discloses a work-related heart attack, and both recount specific crisis-response actions - but they are newly appointed public-school superintendents with no B2B relevance whatsoever, and their 'newly appointed' status limits the depth of at-scale, longitudinal evidence they can offer.
Averaged across 1 recently scored episode, with cited evidence.
The episode has a handful of practical leadership tactics - using opening pleasantries as a mental-health temperature check, or sitting in a principal's school so they can genuinely unplug - but the majority of airtime is consumed by motivational platitudes, adaptive-leadership generalities, and a lengthy retelling of 'The Miracle Morning' SAVERS framework. A B2B operator would find very little here that isn't obvious.
“before I start any meeting or any engagement with a school leader, the first five to 10 minutes is what I call pleasantries. And through the pleasant, if we can't get past the pleasantries, then I don't get into the work.”
“Every email I send principles at the end of the week, it ends with you need to pour it back into your own cup.”
The episode leans heavily on borrowed content - a multi-minute walkthrough of the SAVERS acronym from a popular self-help book, a Les Brown quote, Jim Rohn habits - rather than offering any first-principles or contrarian thinking. The one genuinely distinctive tactic (stepping into a principal's building so they can truly disconnect) is touched on briefly and not developed.
“it's called savers. So silence, which is meditation for 10 minutes. And I use the Calm Map too. So 10-minute meditation, 10-minute affirmation, 10-minute to visualize your day”
“Les Brown says it's better to be prepared for an opportunity and not get one than to get an opportunity to not be prepared”
Both guests are genuine practitioners with lived principal and district-leadership experience - one candidly discloses a work-related heart attack, and both recount specific crisis-response actions - but they are newly appointed public-school superintendents with no B2B relevance whatsoever, and their 'newly appointed' status limits the depth of at-scale, longitudinal evidence they can offer.
“I don't know if you heard Kareem, but I suffered a heart attack two years ago, man, in doing his work.”
“Called my whole network. We got a group chat. Hey, if you guys can spare your counselor, please send them over. I had about eight counselors there.”
The episode includes a handful of concrete anecdotes (eight counselors mobilized, a second-grade student death, an enrollment increase attributed to one leader) but almost no data on outcomes, no program metrics, and many claims rest on personal feeling rather than evidence. The 21/30-day habit statistic is cited without a source and is widely contested pop-psychology.
“I had about eight counselors there. You know, I went in and wrote the letter for the principal that was going to be sent out to the families.”
“he increased enrollment, I believe, by like 3,000 students, man, since he's gotten there”
The host poses reasonable framing questions but never challenges a single claim, lets the guests summarize a self-help book for several minutes without redirection, and devotes the final third of the episode to a completely substance-free 'dream dinner' segment. There is no follow-up probing, no productive friction, and no attempt to surface disagreement between the two guests.
“How do you know when a principal is in trouble?”
“there is a dinner and you are allowed to bring three guests to the dinner and the guests can be dead or alive who are you bringing the dinner”
First period on the Index - history builds from here.
1 scored on substance · 22 tracked in total.
Add this badge to your site - it links back here and updates automatically as you rank.
<a href="https://index.fame.so/show/next-man-up-an-mcel-podcast" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
<img src="https://index.fame.so/badge/next-man-up-an-mcel-podcast/badge.svg" alt="Ranked #745 on The B2B Podcast Index" width="360" height="136" />
</a>Track Next Man Up: An MCEL Podcast's rank
Get an email whenever this show moves up or down the Index. Monthly at most, no spam.
The themes that come up most across this show's episodes.
Podcasts that dig into the same topics.