Fireside Product Management · 2025-10-24 · 29 min
I didn’t plan to make a video today. I’d just wrapped a client call, remembered that OpenAI had released Atlas , and decided to record a quick unboxing for my Fireside PM community. I’d heard mixed things - some people raving about it, others underwhelmed - but I made a deliberate choice not to read any reviews beforehand. I wanted to go in blind, the way an actual user would. Within 30 minutes, I had my verdict: Atlas earns a C+. It’s ambitious, it’s fast, and it hints at a radical new way to experience the web. But it also stumbles in ways that remind you just how fragile early AI products can be - especially when ambition outpaces usability. This post isn’t a teardown or a fan letter. It’s a field report from someone who’s built and shipped dozens of products, from scrappy startups to billion-user platforms. My goal here is simple: unpack what Atlas gets wrong, acknowledge what it gets right, and pull out lessons every PM and product team can use. The Unboxing Experience When I first launched Atlas, I got the usual macOS security warning. I’m not docking points for that - this is an MVP, and once it hits the Mac App Store, those prompts will fade into the background.
From Band Drummer to BizDev to XFN Leader65 / 100
Why Your Next PM Job Depends More on Culture Than Compensation
I Tested 5 AI Tools to Write a PRD - Here's the Winner
The Future of Product Management in the Age of AI: Lessons From a Five Leader Panel
The Difference Between Encouragement and Truth: Lessons From Building What People Actually Need