The B2B Podcast Index
Index
All categories
MarketingSalesSaaSFinanceHROpsLeadershipCustomer SuccessAI & DataProductStartups & FoundersRevOpsEngineering & DevTools
MethodologySubmit
Best of:MarketingSalesSaaSFinanceHROpsLeadershipCustomer SuccessAI & DataProductStartups & FoundersRevOpsEngineering & DevTools
An independent project byFame
SearchBest episodesGuestsInsightsMethodologySubmit a podcast
Index/Leadership/Leadership and Life Essentials with Jacquie
Leadership and Life Essentials with Jacquie artwork

Leadership and Life Essentials: Identify, Define, Reinforce - A Framework for Core Values

Leadership and Life Essentials with Jacquie · 2026-08-31 · 13 min

0:00--:--

Key moments - from our scoring

Substance score

29 / 100

Five dimensions, 20 points each

Insight Density9 / 20
Originality6 / 20
Guest Caliber3 / 20
Specificity & Evidence7 / 20
Conversational Craft4 / 20

Jackie Surgener Galeoni breaks down why most organizations fail to operationalize their core values, even when they've documented them. The core problem: values are named but not defined, leaving employees to guess at what they actually mean in practice. She illustrates this with an example of a "go beyond" value that one manager interpreted as mandatory overtime, undermining the intended meaning of delivering excellent client service. The episode maps a practical three-step process: Identify values by examining your best people and proudest decisions; Define them by writing specific behaviors that exemplify each value (using action verbs, not nouns); and Reinforce them through hiring, firing, promotion, recognition, and decision evaluation. Drawing on research from Brené Brown and frameworks from Gina Wickman (EOS) and Jim Collins, Surgener Galeoni argues that only 10% of organizations actually translate values into teachable, accountable behaviors. The framework emphasizes specificity - including guardrails and trade-offs between competing values - and cultural consistency through tangible reinforcement mechanisms like values-aligned interview questions and employee recognition programs.

Key takeaways

  • →Values must be defined with specific, observable behaviors - not just named - or employees will interpret them inconsistently, creating cultural fragmentation.
  • →Reinforcement through hiring, promotion, and recognition is essential; tolerating values-violating behavior in high performers actively undermines your stated culture.
  • →Writing definitions that include guardrails and trade-offs between competing values prevents overextension (e.g., 'serve others' paired with 'prioritize family' clarifies when to say no).
  • →Brené Brown's research shows only 10% of organizations turn values into teachable, accountable behaviors; the other 90% either ignore values or operate in cultural chaos.
  • →Using values-tied interview questions and recognition criteria shifts culture-fit from a vague gut feeling to a measurable, defensible standard that candidates and employees can understand.

Topics in this episode

Core Values Framework (Identify, Define, Reinforce)Values-based hiring and interview designBrené Brown cultural research (10% implementation rate)Gina Wickman EOS (Entrepreneurial Operating System)Jim Collins First, Then WhatValues reinforcement through recognition and promotionBehavior-based value definitionsCultural consistency and decision-makingEmployee of the Month program redesignGuardrails in competing values

Questions this episode answers

What's the difference between naming values and defining them?

Naming assigns a label (like 'integrity'); defining means writing out the specific behaviors that exemplify that value and clarifying guardrails around it. Without definition, different people fill in the blank themselves, creating inconsistency.

How do you identify your organization's core values if you don't have them yet?

Look at your best people, your proudest decisions, and moments where you did the right thing despite cost or inconvenience. Your actual operating values are already there; identification is about discovering and articulating them.

What does it mean to 'verb' a core value?

Convert nouns or adjectives into action verbs that tell someone how to behave - for example, 'serve others' instead of 'service,' so the value directs behavior rather than remaining abstract.

How should you reinforce core values after defining them?

Embed them in hiring (interview questions tied to behaviors), promotion decisions, employee recognition programs, and performance evaluation. You must also be willing to fire or address employees who consistently violate values, even if they hit KPIs.

What happens if you don't define what a value means?

Managers and teams will interpret it according to their own frameworks, creating inconsistency. For example, 'go beyond' became 'mandatory overtime' under one manager, undermining the intended meaning of excellent client service.

What our scoring noted

Our reviewer’s read on each dimension, with quotes from the episode.

Insight Density

9 / 20

The episode offers a few genuinely useful practical ideas - 'verbing' values, pre-writing behaviors to create guardrails between competing values, and the point that tolerating anti-value behavior while KPIs are hit actively undermines culture. However, the pace is slow and many minutes are spent on motivational framing and platitudes rather than dense insight.

I think it's important to verb them up too. They should tell someone how to act, and a noun or adjective just doesn't do that.
If someone consistently isn't living the values that you've defined and you let it slide because they hit their numbers. Everyone else on the team is seeing that too. They notice what you tolerate as closely as what you celebrate.

Originality

6 / 20

The three-step framework leans heavily on well-circulated ideas from Jim Collins, Gino Wickman, and Brené Brown without meaningfully extending or challenging them; the 'verb your values' framing is mildly fresh but the overall content sits squarely in mainstream leadership consulting orthodoxy.

Gina Wickman, who founded eos, the entrepreneurial operating system, says you hire, fire, reward, promote and recognize based on values. An idea that he pulls from Jim Collins, who first, then what?
Bernay calls this clear as kind.

Guest Caliber

3 / 20

This is a solo episode with no guest; the host is a small-firm leadership consultant who references anonymous client engagements but demonstrates no practitioner experience at meaningful scale, making this dimension essentially inapplicable.

I'm your host, Jackie Surgeon Ergaleni from Leadership in Life by K Rec.
I work with organizations to do this work. I developed a hiring guide with questions designed specifically to evaluate fit to values.

Specificity & Evidence

7 / 20

The 'go beyond' manager anecdote and the hiring-guide outcome story add some concreteness, but all clients are anonymous, no companies are named, no dollar figures or growth metrics appear, and the single statistic cited (Brené Brown's 10%) is unattributed to a primary source.

I worked with an organization where one of their core values was go beyond.
In talking with the founder a couple of months later, he told me they started hiring the right people intentionally rather than just going on gut feel.

Conversational Craft

4 / 20

As a solo monologue, there are no interviewer questions, no follow-ups, and no opportunity for pushback or productive disagreement; the host uses rhetorical questions to the listener which create some engagement but cannot substitute for actual conversational craft.

Can you name it? What about others in your organization? If you asked different people, could they name all your values?
When is the last time you fired someone who didn't live your core values?

Conversation analysis

Computed from the transcript - who did the talking, and the words that came up most.

Most-used words

values44core17value13team10define9culture8defined8behaviors8organization7decisions7leadership6show6live6step6life5last5

Episode notes

When a key person leaves, most leaders are left scrambling, because the talent was never identified or prepared to step up. A real leadership pipeline means you're ready before that moment hits, not after. Promoting someone who isn't readydoesn't just create a rocky transition, it can cost you the person you promoted too.

Full transcript

13 min

Transcribed and scored by The B2B Podcast Index.

Speaker A: Foreign M welcome to Leadership and Life Essentials with Jackie, where I cut through the noise and deliver concise, actionable insights on effective leadership. I'm your host, Jackie Surgeon Ergaleni from Leadership in Life by K Rec. In a world overflowing with information, this show offers short, focused episodes packed with tangible advice and tools to help you lead and live better. Let's dive in. Welcome to Leadership and Life Essentials. This is episode 98 culture isn't an Accident why Values need to be defined, Not Just named. You've got a value statement somewhere. Maybe you've even added it into your website, an employee handbook, and possibly even into job postings. Big check. You've nailed it right? Now. Think about the last decision you made because of those values. Can you name it? What about others in your organization? If you asked different people, could they name all your values? Could they actually describe what they mean and and are they the same? Most leaders can't describe how their values translate into decisions. Most employees can't name or describe an organization's core values. When core values are treated like a checkbox, check it off and it's done. Rather than incorporating them into decisions, discussions, praise, hiring, and the overall running of the organization, they aren't functional, real or useful. Meanwhile, M your team is still making decisions every single day, with or without a value, telling them how Someone's deciding right now whether to tell a client the truth about a missed deadline or to soften it, whether to stay late to fix something or let it wait until tomorrow. If your values were never actually defined, then they're guessing at what you'd want. Or they aren't even paying attention to the values since they aren't even real to the organization. They're making decisions according to their own values or their own framework, not the one that you want for the organization. I want to share a three step framework for your core values. Identify, Define, Reinforce. You need all three. Omit one, and your core values don't drive decisions and behavior. Identify comes first, and it's simpler than most people expect. You aren't starting from scratch. You have values even if you can't articulate them. Look at your best people. Look at the decisions you're proudest of, the ones where you handled something the right way even though it cost you time or money or comfort. Maybe it's the time someone on your team caught a mistake and told the client before they even noticed, instead of hoping it just slipped by. It's really about discovering what's most important. You don't need the perfect word. And you don't need to worry about whether you picked respect or integrity. The important part will come when you move to step two. Define your values are likely already there and operating. Or at least they were when you were a startup before you scaled. While many people work on, uh, narrowing it down from a list of values, I recommend a different process when I work with organizations to do this work. I even followed this process when I identified and defined my own personal core values. I think it's important to verb them up too. They should tell someone how to act, and a noun or adjective just doesn't do that. My personal core values are prioritize family, live with integrity, and serve others. One thing worth knowing. As you go through this, the exact word matters less than what you actually think. Some people get caught up between respect and integrity. Let's say as you go through the define step, you can use one to define the other so you aren't losing it. For me, I define live with integrity as, uh, stating I treat others with respect because I believe I can't demonstrate integrity. Without respect, someone else is doing this work might land in the same place and called accountability instead. Similar ideas will often fold into each other more than you split them apart. The point isn't actually the word, it's what's underneath it. And it isn't just a team exercise. If you're running solo right now, you still have a culture. You're just the only one who has to be intentional about it. Which naturally brings us to step two, which I've been talking about a little bit already. And it's the one that most people skip. Define. I worked with an organization where one of their core values was go beyond. When the executive team landed on it, they were clear deliver an excellent client experience and result. But nobody had ever written down what it actually meant in practice. One manager decided it meant working huge amounts of overtime, grinding, staying late most nights, and then expecting his team to do the same. That was never the intention, though. The value was about delivering an excellent client experience, going the extra step for the person that you're serving, not burning your people out to prove commitment. But without a written definition, he m filled in that blank himself. And once he did, that interpretation became the culture for his whole team. And this created a situation where his team was evaluated against a different standard than other teams. If you don't clearly define what the value means, what behaviors you expect to see, then you run the risk that someone else gets to put their spin on it. And that breeds inconsistency which is the opposite of what you want. Brene Brown has a stat that she shared that has really stuck with me. Only about 10% of organizations actually turn their values into behaviors that can be taught and then held accountable to. 10% is pretty low. The other 90% either don't follow their values or. Or it's the Wild west with everyone interpreting the values in their own way. Worst of all, there might be no values evident at all. Defining simply means describing the behaviors that exemplify that value. For my value of serve others, I named it and then I wrote out what it actually means. I help when I can. I ask what someone needs instead of assuming I already know, and I decline when I can't bring real value to a situation. That last part is important to me. Serve others could be overwhelming without guardrails around it. And as part of my definition, I was able to put up those guardrails. Serve others could easily run me into over committing and it would pull directly against another one of my values. Prioritize family. Writing out the behaviors ahead of time is what lets me say no without a, uh, made up excuse and without the guilt. I know exactly why I'm saying it, and so would anyone if I explained it to them. Bernay calls this clear as kind. Being specific about a value means including what it means to say no. And saying that is kinder than leaving people to guess and to get it wrong. So you've identified your values and now you've defined them with real behaviors, including where they push back on each other. Now step three Reinforce them. Values become embedded when they're part of a conversation. Constantly. Gina Wickman, who founded eos, the entrepreneurial operating system, says you hire, fire, reward, promote and recognize based on values. An idea that he pulls from Jim Collins, who first, then what? When you incorporate values into praise and ensure the people you promote live your values, you're, um, embedding your values. The true test is when decisions are evaluated against your core values. Many businesses stop at hiring uh, to core values if they use their values at all. When is the last time you fired someone who didn't live your core values? What about praising someone using a specific example of how they lived a core value, all the while naming the core value. Could every employee in your organization name your core values? Do you tolerate anti value behaviors? If an employee still hits their KPIs, then you're actively, even if unintentionally, undermining your values and your culture. If someone consistently isn't living the values that you've defined and you let it slide because they hit their numbers. Everyone else on the team is seeing that too. They notice what you tolerate as closely as what you celebrate. I work with organizations to do this work. I developed a hiring guide with questions designed specifically to evaluate fit to values. Questions built to elicit examples and even more important, non examples of the behaviors that we defined. In talking with the founder a couple of months later, he told me they started hiring the right people intentionally rather than just going on gut feel. And a few candidates self selected out before an offer was even on the table because the questions made it obvious for them that they weren't a right fit. Before that guide existed, fit was just a feeling on their team. It was big, hard to explain, easy to get wrong. Afterwards, it was something that they could point to. Another leader I worked with used the same idea on the recognition side. Their Employee of the Month program had gone flat. Submissions were low and often thin. It was just the same vague praise over and over. So they rewrote the criteria around their actual defined values instead of just a general who did something good this month, submissions picked up both in number and actually quality as well, because people finally knew what they were supposed to be looking for. Both organizations have a great culture that's driven by their core values. So let's go back to the question I opened with. Can you name the last decision you made because of one of your values? If the answer came fast, you're probably nailing it and you've done this work, awesome. If it didn't, it's not a failure, it's just where you start working. And we've reached the part of the show where we talk about what you can do. I have lots of blog posts and radio shows about culture and core values. You can read Jim Collins Work on first to then what? Maybe you take one of your existing values and write out three specific, uh, behaviors that show it in action. Try tying your next praise to a core value. Maybe you add one interview question that's tied to a value. You can try asking two people on your team to define one of your core values. If they're not yet defined, use their own words and compare notes to see if they're aligned. Maybe reflect back on your last couple of promotions and ask if they're a culture fit. Do they live your values? If you want support to do this work, reach out. I love doing it. For resources related to this show, you can check out the show page at ah leadershipandlife cashow98 and remember your culture requires you to identify and define your values and then continually reinforce them. You've reached the end of another episode of Leadership and Life Essentials. If you want to learn more about today's topics, please visit leadershipandlife Ca, where you'll find episode show notes and free bonus resources. I'm Jackie Sergener Galeoni, founder of Leadership and Life by Kric, Inc. Where I strive to empower leaders with the skills no one taught them to create teams who want to work together. Thanks for joining me.

More from Leadership and Life Essentials with Jacquie

All episodes →
  • Leadership and Life Essentials: The Space You're Skipping - Why Busy Leaders Need Reflection Most43 / 100
  • Leadership and Life Essentials: More Than Your Style - How DISC Builds Stronger, More Cohesive Teams42 / 100
  • Leadership and Life Essentials: Stop Hiding Behind Your Inbox - Three Ways Leaders Misuse Email44 / 100
  • Leadership and Life Essentials: Same Page or Same Blind Spot - Why Team Composition Matters More Than You Think46 / 100
  • Leadership and Life Essentials: The Hiring Filter You're Not Using - How Your Core Values Should Drive Every Interview49 / 100
Explore the best B2B Leadership podcasts →
All Leadership and Life Essentials with Jacquie episodes →